Reducing your product carbon footprint (PCF) and analyzing Scope 3 emissions are vital for a comprehensive sustainability strategy. Choosing the right platform is crucial. This report compares Arbor and Worldly to help you make an informed decision.
Worldly
Worldly (formerly Higg) provides sustainability data insights for a large network of brands and manufacturers. They focus on collecting primary ESG data across supply chains and products. Worldly leverages the Higg Index suite of tools extensively.
Key Features
- Product Impact Calculator (PIC) for Scope 3 emissions data.
- Integration with Higg Facility Environmental Module (FEM) and Materials Sustainability Index (MSI).
- Scalable solutions for large and complex supply chains.
Pros
- Fast Scope 3 data generation, especially for initial assessments.
- Primary data incorporation for improved accuracy.
- Strong industry expertise and data within the apparel sector.
- Integration with the Higg Index suite for existing users.
Cons
- High Cost: Starting at > $14,000/year.
- Limited Industry Application: Best suited for apparel and textile industries due to Higg Index reliance.
- Controversial Past: Historically associated with the Higg Index controversies, including accusations of greenwashing and data inaccuracies.
- Usage: Not user-friendly, difficult to learn.
Arbor
Arbor provides accurate and actionable product carbon footprinting. Our "bottom-up" methodology delivers precise insights across the entire product lifecycle. We empower sustainability champions with the data they need to drive impactful change.
Key Features
- "Bottom-up" Methodology: Direct carbon impact measurements at the product level.
- Rapid Carbon Footprint Calculations: Get results in as little as 3 minutes.
- Lifecycle Analysis: Track emissions from raw materials to end-of-life.
- Decarbonization Scenario Modeling: Prototype emission reductions at material, product, and supplier levels.
- ISO 14067 Verification: Record breaking speed for verification against globally recognized standards.
- Value Chain-Specific Data: Integration of primary and secondary data for accurate, localized results.
Pros
- Accurate & Reliable Data: "bottom-up" methodology delivers precise and auditable carbon footprints.
- Ease of Use: Streamlined platform for rapid calculations and insightful analysis.
- Comprehensive Lifecycle Analysis: Full visibility into emission hotspots across the product lifecycle.
- Multi-Framework Compliance: Adherence to international standards (ISO 14067, GHG Protocol).
- Shopify Integration: Seamless carbon footprint calculations for apparel businesses using Shopify.
- Affordable Pricing: Starting at $200/product.
Cons
- Limited Integrations: Currently offers only Shopify integration. (Note: Arbor is expanding integrations and offers onboarding support from our team to ensure a smooth transition.)
Arbor vs. Worldly: Key Differences
Here's a quick comparison of key features to help you choose the best platform for your needs:
Arbor: The Clear Choice for Actionable Sustainability
For accurate, reliable, and affordable product carbon footprinting, Arbor is the superior choice. Our "bottom-up" methodology delivers precise insights you can trust, while our streamlined platform makes it easy to analyze and reduce your environmental impact. While we currently only integrate with Shopify, we are actively expanding our integrations and offering dedicated onboarding support to ensure a seamless experience.
Worldly's strength lies within the apparel and textile industry and for those already heavily invested in the Higg Index. However, their higher cost and past controversies may give you pause.
%20Arbor%20Canada.webp)
.webp)
%20Arbor.webp)
.webp)
_.webp)
.webp)
%20Arbor.avif)
%20Software%20and%20Tools.avif)
.avif)
.avif)
%20EU%20Regulation.avif)
.avif)
%20Arbor.avif)
_%20_%20Carbon%20101.avif)
.avif)
.avif)
.avif)
.avif)
.avif)
